EPISODE GUESTS
Paul Tutton is a Product Manager at Moneyhub, specialising in payments, APIs, Open Banking and financial technology. His work covers Smart Payments, Pay by Bank, Variable Recurring Payments and automated cash movement, with a focus on helping businesses connect their systems to modern financial infrastructure and create faster, more flexible financial services.
SHOW NOTES
Key Topics Discussed:
What transaction data enrichment actually does
Why accurate transaction categorisation matters
Using open banking data for affordability assessments
How better financial data can improve lending decisions
Variable Recurring Payments and commercial VRP
Pay by Bank adoption and payment UX
Using transaction data to improve customer experience
How banks can turn financial data into better products
Episode Summary:
This episode gets into transaction data enrichment, and why it matters for banks, lenders and financial services businesses making decisions from customer data. Paul Tutton, Product Manager at Moneyhub, joins Grant Evans and Justin Hanna to discuss transaction categorisation, open banking affordability, lending, Variable Recurring Payments and Pay by Bank.
The conversation looks at a basic problem with big consequences: raw transaction data can be messy, cryptic and difficult for both consumers and financial institutions to interpret.
Transaction data enrichment takes that raw information and makes it more useful. Transactions can be categorised and supplemented with information such as merchant details and location data, giving financial institutions a clearer picture of where money is going and what that activity means.
That matters because once businesses start making decisions from transaction data, poor-quality information can quickly lead to poor-quality outcomes.
What is transaction data enrichment?
Transaction data enrichment is the process of taking raw financial transaction information and adding context that makes it easier to understand and use.
Paul explains that some banking transactions already contain useful information. Others can be exceptionally difficult for customers to interpret.
That creates what he describes as a “confusion tax”.
When customers cannot recognise a transaction, they are more likely to contact their bank or financial provider. Moneyhub estimates those queries can cost providers around £7.20 each.
Better transaction categorisation can reduce that confusion while also creating a more useful dataset for financial institutions.
Moneyhub says its latest categorisation and enrichment engine operates at around 98% accuracy, using additional card transaction information and location data alongside its existing dataset.
The commercial value goes much further than presenting a cleaner transaction description on a banking app.
Why does accurate transaction categorisation matter?
Once transaction data is being used to make financial decisions, accuracy becomes much more important.
A miscategorised coffee might be a minor annoyance on a banking app.
Misinterpreting someone's spending patterns when assessing whether they can afford a loan has potentially much bigger consequences.
Paul explains that Moneyhub uses deterministic AI rather than relying entirely on probabilistic models. The aim is to work within a more bounded dataset and create an audit trail behind transaction categorisation.
That becomes particularly important when dealing with large regulated financial institutions.
Banks and lenders need to understand how decisions have been reached rather than relying on a system that effectively produces an unexplained answer.
How can open banking data improve affordability assessments?
Traditional affordability assessments commonly rely heavily on credit reference agency data.
That remains useful, but Paul describes it as relatively backward-looking.
Open banking provides another layer because lenders can analyse recent transaction activity when the customer gives permission.
That can provide signals about what is happening financially right now.
Moneyhub looks at areas such as gambling activity, proximity to salary, failed Direct Debits, Buy Now Pay Later commitments and whether someone appears to be stacking personal loans.
Those signals can then be grouped into risk areas and presented to the lender.
The lender still decides its own risk appetite. The difference is that it has a richer picture on which to base that decision.
Can better data help lenders approve more customers?
One of the more interesting commercial arguments in the episode is that better affordability data doesn't necessarily mean declining more applications.
It can also help lenders identify people who may be safe to lend to but who are poorly represented by traditional credit data.
Paul points to thin-file customers, gig-economy workers, self-employed people and people returning to the UK after living abroad.
Someone may have limited conventional credit history but still have months of transaction data demonstrating their financial position.
Moneyhub says organisations it has worked with have seen an 18% uplift in loans approved, alongside a 48% reduction in missed first payments and a 36% reduction over the first six months.
These figures are Moneyhub examples discussed by Paul in the episode rather than general industry benchmarks.
Why context matters when analysing spending
The discussion around gambling provides a useful example of why categorisation alone isn't enough.
Spending £100 a month on gambling does not necessarily carry the same meaning for every customer.
Income, wider spending behaviour, frequency and type of gambling all matter.
Paul also points out that something such as National Lottery spending can be grouped into gambling if the categorisation isn't sufficiently detailed.
The challenge for lenders is therefore to avoid reducing financial behaviour to simplistic labels.
Better data provides the context. The lender then needs to apply its own risk policies to that information.
Where do Variable Recurring Payments fit?
The conversation also moves into Variable Recurring Payments, or VRPs.
Moneyhub is already seeing adoption of sweeping VRPs, including moving money automatically into savings.
The advantage over a fixed Direct Debit is flexibility.
A traditional savings Direct Debit might take the same amount on the same day every month regardless of the customer's financial position.
A VRP can be combined with account information to make that process more responsive.
If someone's balance is unusually low, for example, the provider could decide not to take the savings payment and tell the customer why.
Paul argues this can support financial wellbeing while also helping providers demonstrate their Consumer Duty responsibilities.
Moneyhub expects commercial VRP to open up significantly more use cases as industry adoption develops.
How can open banking data improve customer experience?
Better financial data also changes what banks can show customers.
Instead of displaying a cryptic transaction reference, an institution can potentially show the correct merchant name, location, website, phone number and spending category.
For incumbent banks, that matters competitively.
Paul points out that large banks increasingly compete with neobanks that have made richer transaction information a normal part of the banking experience.
If customers can get a clearer financial picture somewhere else, there is a risk they move their primary financial relationship there too.
Transaction enrichment therefore becomes partly a customer-retention issue.
What does better data mean for financial products?
The opportunity becomes more interesting when financial institutions use enriched data beyond transaction histories.
Open banking data can help product teams understand customer behaviour, segment users and identify potentially relevant products.
Paul gives the example of seeing when a customer's car insurance payments occur. A financial institution with an insurance business could potentially use that information to make a more relevant offer at the right time.
The same principle could apply to subscriptions, credit products and other financial services.
That needs to be handled responsibly, but it shows why transaction data is becoming strategically important.
The value isn't simply knowing where someone spent money. It is understanding enough context to build better financial experiences around that information.
Where does Pay by Bank fit into the data story?
Pay by Bank provides another example of how open banking is moving closer to the mainstream.
Paul says Moneyhub has seen strong uptake where Pay by Bank is given greater prominence within the payment journey, including adoption of around 70% in one customer example.
He also points to conversion rates in the high 80s for some Pay by Bank and open banking payment journeys.
Again, these are Moneyhub examples rather than market-wide benchmarks.
The wider lesson is that consumers don't necessarily need to understand the underlying open banking terminology.
They simply need a payment experience that makes sense.
Pre-populated destination account details and payment references can also reduce operational problems for businesses because fewer payments arrive with incorrect or missing information.
From reactive lending to earlier intervention
One of the most interesting future uses of open banking data discussed in the episode is ongoing affordability monitoring.
Instead of assessing affordability only when a loan originates, ongoing consent could potentially allow lenders to identify significant changes in a customer's financial circumstances.
That creates the possibility of intervening before someone falls into arrears.
A lender might see that cash flow has changed and start a conversation about extending a loan term, restructuring repayments or offering a payment holiday.
For lenders, that could reduce the cost and risk associated with collections.
For customers, it could mean support arrives before financial difficulty becomes a missed payment.
The big takeaway: transaction data becomes more valuable when financial institutions can turn it into accurate, usable context. For banks, lenders and fintechs, that means treating transaction data enrichment as an input into affordability, product design, payments and customer experience rather than simply making statements look cleaner. Get that right, and better data can support smarter decisions for both businesses and customers. Get it wrong, and poor-quality information simply gets carried into the next decision.
MEET THE HOSTS

Co-Host and Co-Founder of The Payments Shed Podcast
Grant Evans
Grant Evans is a leading voice in the fintech industry and the creator of the widely followed ‘The Payments Shed Newsletter’. With more than 15 years experience shaping commercial strategy and driving partnership growth, he is recognised for turning complex topics such as embedded payments, BNPL, unified commerce, and open banking into clear, actionable insights that resonate with global audiences. Named a LinkedIn Top Voice in both 2024 and 2025, Grant has built a community of over 27,000 engaged professionals, merchants, and innovators who look to him for commentary on the trends redefining global commerce. A sought-after speaker and panelist, his thought leadership is regularly featured in financial services publications and at flagship industry events including Money 20/20, FTT Fintech and the Global RegTech Summit.

Co-Host and Co-Founder of The Payments Shed Podcast
Justin Hanna
Justin Hanna was recently named the #1 Head of Sales Top Voice by the National Sales Conference for good reason: he’s redefining what sales leadership looks like in the modern era. With deep B2B sales experience and a people-first approach, Justin earns trust through insight and practical strategy, not tired tactics. A respected voice in payments, he’s also built a 22,000-strong LinkedIn following by making complex topics relatable and actionable. His influence has been recognised widely: a LinkedIn Top Payment Systems Voice (2024), one of the top 30 voices shaping the future of payments, banking, and fintech (2025), and celebrated by the National Sales Conference as the #1 Head of Sales Top Voice. Known for challenging the status quo, Justin’s unfiltered take on leadership, culture, and growth resonates because it’s honest, and his ability to lead with both expertise and empathy has made him one of the most influential sales voices today.
EPISODE TRANSCRIPT
GRANT:
Welcome to The Payments Shed Podcast, the weekly podcast that dives into the big topics, trends and people shaping the worlds of payments, fintech and business leadership, with your two co-hosts, myself, Grant Evans, and Justin Hanna.
Welcome back to The Payments Shed Podcast. Today we are joined by Paul Tutton from Moneyhub.
Paul, thank you so much for joining us on the show today.
PAUL:
Thanks for having me.
GRANT:
Paul, tell us a little bit about yourself and your role at Moneyhub.
PAUL:
I'm a Product Manager at Moneyhub. I specialise in payments, APIs, Open Banking and financial technology.
My work covers Smart Payments, Pay by Bank, Variable Recurring Payments and automated cash movement, with a focus on making financial services faster, more flexible and easier to use.
GRANT:
Let's start with transaction data.
Why does transaction data need enriching in the first place?
PAUL:
Raw transaction data can range from being really useful to exceptionally cryptic.
Sometimes you can immediately understand where you've spent money. Other times, you look at a transaction and have absolutely no idea what it relates to.
That creates what we call a confusion tax.
If customers don't understand a transaction, they're more likely to contact their bank or financial provider and ask what it is.
Those queries have a real cost for providers.
By enriching that transaction data, categorising it properly and adding additional information, you can make it much easier for customers to understand what they've actually spent their money on.
GRANT:
So what does transaction data enrichment actually involve?
PAUL:
It's taking that raw financial transaction information and adding context around it.
That might mean identifying the merchant correctly, categorising the transaction or adding location information.
We've recently launched our latest categorisation and enrichment engine.
We're now operating at around 98% accuracy.
We're using additional card transaction information, location data and the data we've already built up to improve the quality of that categorisation.
GRANT:
And accuracy becomes pretty important when you're using that data to make financial decisions.
PAUL:
Absolutely.
If you're just looking at a transaction in your banking app and a coffee gets categorised incorrectly, that's annoying.
But if you're using transaction data to decide whether somebody can afford a loan, that's very different.
You need confidence in the data you're using.
That's why we've focused on deterministic AI rather than relying entirely on probabilistic models.
We want to work within a bounded dataset and have an audit trail behind how transactions are being categorised.
That becomes particularly important when you're dealing with large regulated financial institutions.
They need to understand how you've reached a decision. You can't just give them an answer and say, "The AI told us."
GRANT:
When you start looking at lending and affordability, what can Open Banking data give a lender that traditional credit data can't?
PAUL:
Traditional affordability assessments tend to rely heavily on credit reference agency data.
That's still useful, but it's relatively backward-looking.
Open Banking can give you a much more recent picture of what's actually happening in someone's finances.
With permission, you can analyse their transaction activity and identify different signals.
We look at things such as gambling activity, how close spending is happening to salary, failed Direct Debits, Buy Now Pay Later commitments and whether someone appears to be stacking personal loans.
You can group those signals into different areas of risk and present that information to the lender.
The lender then decides what their own risk appetite is.
We're not necessarily making the lending decision for them. We're giving them a richer picture to make that decision from.
GRANT:
Does richer data always mean becoming more conservative with lending?
PAUL:
No. That's actually one of the interesting things.
Better affordability data can also help lenders identify people who are safe to lend to but aren't represented particularly well by traditional credit data.
Think about thin-file customers.
You might have someone working in the gig economy, somebody who's self-employed or somebody who's been living overseas and has recently returned to the UK.
They might not have a strong traditional credit history.
But they might have months of transaction data that demonstrates their actual financial position.
We've seen organisations we've worked with achieve an 18% uplift in loans approved.
At the same time, we've seen a 48% reduction in missed first payments and a 36% reduction over the first six months.
So you're potentially approving more customers while also improving the quality of the lending.
GRANT:
That's really interesting because it shows why the context around a transaction matters.
You mentioned gambling. That's an area where context must be particularly important.
PAUL:
Absolutely.
If somebody spends £100 a month on gambling, that doesn't necessarily mean the same thing for every customer.
You have to look at their income, their wider spending behaviour, the frequency and what type of gambling it actually is.
Something like National Lottery spending might be categorised as gambling.
If you're not careful, you can reduce someone's financial behaviour to a very simplistic label.
That's why you need more context around the data.
The data gives the lender the information, and then the lender applies their own risk policies around that.
GRANT:
How much does this improve the customer experience as well?
PAUL:
A lot.
If you open your banking app and see a transaction with a completely cryptic reference, that's not particularly helpful.
If instead you can see the correct merchant name, location, website, phone number and spending category, you've immediately got a much better experience.
For incumbent banks, that's increasingly important because they're competing against neobanks that have made richer transaction information a normal part of banking.
Customers are getting used to better experiences.
If they can get a clearer view of their finances somewhere else, there's a risk that their primary financial relationship moves somewhere else as well.
GRANT:
So transaction enrichment becomes a retention issue as well as a data issue?
PAUL:
Potentially, yes.
It's about making the information more useful to the customer, but there's also a much bigger opportunity for the financial institution.
Once you've got good transaction data, you can start understanding customer behaviour much better.
You can segment customers and potentially identify products that are relevant to them.
If you can see when someone's car insurance payments happen, for example, and you're a bank with an insurance business, you might be able to make them a relevant offer at the right time.
You obviously need to do that responsibly.
But it demonstrates that transaction data isn't simply about making the description in a banking app look nicer.
It can become a strategic asset.
GRANT:
Let's move into Variable Recurring Payments.
Where are you seeing VRPs being used today?
PAUL:
We're already seeing adoption of sweeping VRPs.
A good example is automatically moving money into savings.
The advantage compared with a traditional Direct Debit is flexibility.
If you've got a savings Direct Debit that takes £200 on the same day every month, it's going to try and take that £200 regardless of what your finances look like at that moment.
With a VRP, you can combine the payment capability with account information.
You might see that the customer's balance is unusually low that month and decide not to take the savings payment.
You can tell the customer why.
That can support financial wellbeing and it can also help providers demonstrate their Consumer Duty responsibilities.
GRANT:
So it's almost a smarter version of recurring payments?
PAUL:
That's one way of looking at it.
It's more flexible and can respond to what's actually happening in someone's finances.
The next big area is commercial VRP.
As that develops, you're going to see many more potential use cases.
GRANT:
How far away do you think commercial VRP is from becoming something we see at scale?
PAUL:
There's still work to do across the industry.
You've got questions around pricing, commercial models and adoption.
But there's a lot of potential.
Once you can combine account information with the ability to move money flexibly, you can start creating much more intelligent payment experiences.
GRANT:
And Pay by Bank is another area that's moved forward quite quickly.
What are you seeing there?
PAUL:
We've seen really strong uptake where Pay by Bank is given enough prominence in the payment journey.
We've seen around 70% adoption in one customer example.
We've also seen conversion rates in the high 80s on some Pay by Bank and Open Banking payment journeys.
A lot comes down to the customer experience.
Consumers don't necessarily need to understand the phrase "Open Banking".
They just need the payment journey to make sense.
GRANT:
That's always been one of my arguments.
The customer doesn't care what's happening underneath.
They just want it to work.
PAUL:
Exactly.
One of the benefits of Pay by Bank is that you can pre-populate things like the destination account and the payment reference.
That sounds simple, but it removes a lot of operational problems.
If someone manually makes a bank transfer and puts the wrong reference in, the business then has to work out where that payment belongs.
If you can automate that information, you've immediately removed some friction for both sides.
GRANT:
It comes back to better data again.
PAUL:
Exactly.
A lot of this is really about the quality of the information and how you use it.
The payment itself might only be one part of the journey.
GRANT:
Where do you see Open Banking data going next?
PAUL:
One area I'm particularly interested in is ongoing affordability monitoring.
At the moment, affordability is often assessed when a loan originates.
You make the decision and then, unless something goes wrong, you may not have much visibility of how the customer's financial circumstances are changing.
With ongoing consent, Open Banking could potentially allow lenders to identify significant changes earlier.
If someone's cash flow changes materially, you might be able to start a conversation before they miss a payment.
Maybe you extend the term of the loan, restructure repayments or offer a payment holiday.
That can be better for the lender because collections are expensive and risky.
It can also be much better for the customer because you're potentially offering support before they fall into financial difficulty.
GRANT:
That feels like a big shift from reactive to proactive.
PAUL:
Exactly.
Rather than waiting for somebody to miss a payment and then starting the collections process, you could potentially identify that they're heading towards difficulty and intervene earlier.
That's where good data becomes really powerful.
GRANT:
How do you balance that with the obvious concerns around privacy and customers feeling like their bank is watching everything they're doing?
PAUL:
Consent is obviously fundamental.
Customers need to understand what they're agreeing to and what the data is being used for.
There also needs to be a clear value exchange.
If you're asking someone to share financial data, they need to understand how that benefits them.
Maybe it gives them access to a better lending decision.
Maybe it helps prevent them from falling into arrears.
Maybe it gives them a better financial management experience.
The use case needs to be clear.
GRANT:
Do you think banks are making enough use of the data they already have?
PAUL:
Probably not.
There is a huge amount of information available.
The challenge is turning that information into something useful.
That's where enrichment and categorisation come in.
Raw data on its own isn't necessarily valuable.
It's the context around it that allows you to do something useful.
GRANT:
And presumably that becomes even more important as more financial services businesses start building on APIs?
PAUL:
Absolutely.
The infrastructure is becoming increasingly connected.
Open Banking APIs allow businesses to access account information and initiate payments, with customer consent.
But again, access to the data is only part of the story.
You need to be able to understand it and use it.
GRANT:
If we look at the next couple of years, what do you think changes most?
PAUL:
I think you'll see much more intelligent use of transaction data.
You'll see more adoption of Pay by Bank and VRP.
I also think financial institutions will increasingly realise that data enrichment isn't just a nice customer experience feature.
It can feed into risk, lending, customer service, product development and payments.
The organisations that can combine those pieces effectively will be able to create much more personalised financial experiences.
GRANT:
Before we wrap up, we always have our Shelf of Shame.
What would you like to banish from payments or fintech forever?
PAUL:
Bad transaction descriptions.
When you open your banking app and see something that bears no resemblance whatsoever to the company you actually paid.
You sit there trying to remember what you bought three days ago.
I'd happily get rid of those forever.
GRANT:
Very relevant to today's conversation.
PAUL:
Exactly.
GRANT:
Paul, thank you so much for joining us.
Where can people find you and find out more about Moneyhub?
PAUL:
You can find me on LinkedIn, and you can find Moneyhub online as well.
GRANT:
Amazing. Paul, thanks so much for joining us.
PAUL:
Thanks for having me.
Join the podcast for a relaxed conversation where you can share your experience and perspective with people working across the payments industry.
Be a Guest on the Podcast
Sponsor the podcast and get your brand featured in front of the top players in the Payments and fintech industry.